Tuesday, May 13, 2014

Please give a critical analysis for "The Signal-Man."

Well, there are certainly many different aspects that you
could focus on in this excellent short story by Dickens. One of them which I find rather
interesting is the symbolism of the railway and how this is linked in with the themes of
the story. Essentially the story concerns a phantom that warns or informs a helpless
watcher of a fatal accident that is just about to happen or has already happened. In
Victorian literature, the railway was a highly ambiguous symbol, as it symbolised fears
about technological advances and how they could destroy traditional ways of living,
exchanging close and personal connections with more impersonal mechanical procedures. We
can see this anxiety in this short story by the way in which tragedies occur in spite of
all of the mechanical means of ensuring safety. In spite of signal lights, telegraphs
wires and safety lights, the signal-man is haunted by the fact that he is unable to stop
the tragedies that occur.


Even though the signal-man is
presented as being diligent and hardworking, not shirking in his duty in anyway, it is
clear that this is not enough to prevent the tragedies from occurring, and it is this as
well that makes him so upset and disturbed. Note how he himself says he used to be a
"contended man" but that now he is "troubled" because of these happenings. In spite of
the technological advances and mechanical safety systems, the train appears to possess
an untamed energy that operates as it will in spite of the systems created by its
inventors. Thus this story could be read as a critique on progress and technological
advances, and how such progress can be dangerous.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Can (sec x - cosec x) / (tan x - cot x) be simplified further?

Given the expression ( sec x - csec x ) / (tan x - cot x) We need to simplify. We will use trigonometric identities ...