[Everyone perceives pieces of art in different ways
depending upon each individual's experiences: this is only my
interpretation.]
The general consensus of the research I
have found on Emily Dickinson's poem, "One need not be a chamber to be haunted," is that
the images she presents compare the threat of material things to the threat of the
workings of our minds and/or hearts.
One reviewer
observes:
To
Dickinson, mental disability is a real and very threatening reality, although we do not
know if or to what extent she personally encountered
it.
It may simply be, as is
often the case with Dickinson, that she is observing this phenomenon, in herself or in
someone else.
Regardless, the first stanza presents the
main idea that reflects the title, for a brain is much like a house with its own haunted
corridors.
The second stanza relates the relative ease one
may approach a real ghost as opposed to the "Cooler host," the mind that haunts us with
ideas, memories, worries, etc.
My interpretation of the
third stanza is that it would be easier to gallop on a horse through an abbey (which is
a holy place, like a monastery or convent) with stones chasing one, than meet up with
yourself or your soul, and confronting it without weapons to defend
you.
The "stones a'chase" could be interpreted one of two
ways, as I see it. First, if the abbey
is old and falling down, as they were built of stone, if the building were falling to
ruin (perhaps a more logical circumstance when one might find
himself on a horse within such a place), then the galloping might dislodge old stones,
or they might be falling anyway and the speed of the horse would aid the rider in
avoiding injury from those stones.
However, if one were
within the abbey courtyard and was being attacked (one can only imagine
why this would be the case), the stones may be missiles, weapons
thrown at the rider, which he tries to avoid.
The only
reason I might assume that the stones are being used as weapons is the third line's
reference to "Unarmed, one's a'self encounter / In lonesome Place."
However, the use of "unarmed" may have nothing
to do with the stones, but may stand alone with the sense that there is no weapon that
can defend us from our ideas, especially when things are most upsetting—when we are
alone.
The fourth stanza tells us that it is worse to be
taken by surprise by our thoughts, than by an assassin hidden within our home. The fifth
stanza ties into that same thought: a physical body has a means of defense: take out a
gun, lock the door; but with the mind, "a superior spectre" (ghost, apparition) that
would be, once again, our thoughts, our ideas, our fears,
etc.
It is difficult for me to be certain of Dickinson's
use of apostrophes in "a'chase" and "a'self encounter." In the second and the fourth
line of the third stanza, the author may be trying to add a syllable to provide the same
number of beats in the lines' rhythm. The same may be the case for the first and third
line as well. (There does seem to be a pattern in the second, third and fourth stanzas,
where the second and fourth lines of each have two
beats.)
I hope this is of some
help.
No comments:
Post a Comment