A helpful discussion of Sir Francis Bacon’s essay “Of
Truth” might begin by simply paraphrasing the argument of the essay. Essentially, Bacon
argues as follows:
- Although there are few
philosophical skeptics left, many human beings still seem to prefer the freedom to adopt
their own views over the hard work of pursuing truth, since they consider truth
constricting. - Human beings seem to have a natural
disposition to want to lie. - To many people, simple truth
never seems as attractive as appealing falsehoods. - People
seem to take pleasure in lying. - The worst lies are those
that take deep root in people’s minds. - The pursuit of
truth is, or should be, “the sovereign good of human nature.” After
all,
The first creature of God . . . was the light of
the sense; the last was the light of
reason.
- To possess
truth is like standing on a tall hill and observing the follies and errors of mankind
below. - Yet we should pity those who lack truth rather
than being proud of our superiority to them. Love of our fellow creatures is the true
companion of truth. - Truthfulness should especially be
valued in daily conduct; no sin is more shameful than
lying. - Those who lie to others show their fear of other
humans but their misguided bravery and foolish defiance in dealing with
God.
Bacon’s essay is a typical reflection of
Renaissance thought in a number of ways, including the
following:
- It draws both on Christian scriptures
and on classical literature and classical philosophy to make its points. Since one of
the main purposes of the Renaissance was to reconcile Christian truth with truths also
apparent in the classics, Bacon is here writing as a typical “Renaissance
man.” - Bacon clearly assumes that "truth" should be
identified with the "truths" of Christianity. - It
emphasizes that reason is one of the earliest and most important of all the gifts God
gave to man, and it implies that reason should be used properly – that is, as a means of
discovering truth. - It assumes, as most Renaissance
Christians did, that humans are corrupt by nature (ultimately as a result of the
original sin of Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden).
- However, it also assumes that humans have a moral and
spiritual obligation to struggle against that corruption in order to pursue truth and
thus discover and love God. - It emphasizes another of the
key Christian virtues: charity, or love of other creatures as creatures made and loved
by God. - It doesn’t merely discuss truth in the abstract,
as a simple philosophical concept, but also discusses the importance of truth-telling
and truthful behavior in daily life. In other words, a main purpose of the essay is an
ethical purpose, so that truth is linked with practical
goodness. - It ends by implying that the ultimate judge of
human conduct is and will be God, and that humans should always think of God first in
forming their thoughts and behavior.
No comments:
Post a Comment